« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Deconstructing the American Dream

'That's how we created the middle class.' Wait, what?!

I sat down this morning to write about teachers and bridges, about motivation and inspiration. Upon rereading the President’s Roanoke remarks, however, my focus shifted away from my planned topic of entrepreneurial outrage (“You didn’t build that!”). Reading deeper, a more alarming theme emerged:

Now, we don’t need more top-down economics.  I’ve got a different view.  I believe that the way you grow the economy is from the middle out.  (Applause.)  I believe that you grow the economy from the bottom up.  I believe that when working people are doing well, the country does well.  (Applause.) …

So we say to ourselves, ever since the founding of this country, you know what, there are some things we do better together.  That’s how we funded the GI Bill.  That’s how we created the middle class.  That’s how we built the Golden Gate Bridge or the Hoover Dam.  That’s how we invented the Internet.  That’s how we sent a man to the moon.  We rise or fall together as one nation and as one people, and that’s the reason I’m running for President — because I still believe in that idea.  You’re not on your own, we’re in this together.  (Applause.)

So, contrary to what you may have learned in your reactionary history class in high school, the middle class was not an organic outgrowth of the Industrial Revolution, or the coming-of-age of the mighty American Economy. No, the middle class is a policy construct of government, at least in Obama’s perception.

One thing about this President, he telegraphs his blows. He tells us precisely what he’s about, then he sets about doing it.

The President’s concept of “middle class” diverges radically from the traditional one, the middle class I grew up in. That middle class bought into a concept of the American Dream that included class mobility. Good grades, hard work, passion and a willingness to take some risk were a ticket to a better life.

The President’s vision is of a permanent, entitled Democratic voting majority of comprised of the lower- and working classes, more of a “meso-class” than a true middle class. In this vision, government “safety nets”-cum-hammocks have the necessities (food, shelter, health care) covered. Government even provides some of the trappings of the middle class, like cell phones. Class mobility is punished: anyone who tries to escape the meso-class climbs a steep slope of taxation. Many will judge it not worth the effort, quite a rational decision given the cost of entitlements foregone vs. the risk of failure. Tax collections will fall as the truly rich sit on their assets, absent a motivation to risk capital on new investment. It won’t matter so much, since job creation will be a central function of government, not the private sector. Tax rates will necessarily increase, and the cycle repeats.

The President’s understanding of history is flawed. It’s not that trickle-down economics has been tried and found wanting, it’s never really been tried. The most dramatic period of economic growth and rebirth, at least in my experience, was 1980 to 2000. The foundation of the renaissance was President Reagan’s tax reform, which shifted the economy’s focus away from the avoidance of ridiculously burdensome 70+% marginal tax rates (characterized by abusive tax shelters and intentionally unprofitable investments) toward real, productive economic growth. A Democratic Congress refused to reign in spending, so Reagan got half a measure of what might have been possible, but it undeniably worked.

Today’s Democrats, meanwhile, cling to the notion that we can tax our way to prosperity. This week, Steny Hoyer declared that unemployment benefits and food stamps are the two most effective means at our disposal of stimulating the economy. Left to their own devices, one can be sure that the Democrats would create two new Cabinet-level departments: the Department of Digging Holes and the Department of Filling Them Up.

Cross-posted at Maley’s Energy Blog.


Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • moonmad

    “One thing about this President, he telegraphs his blows. He tells us precisely what he?s about, then he sets about doing it.”

    Those who paid attention could see all his moves coming. We have people who are willingly blind Democrats, the media( I know thats largely redundant), A large part of the established Republican leadership and large swaths of pundits. This is one of the reasons Obama must be laughing. He is a lot like other totalitarians. They tell you what they are going to do to you. I guess another human flaw is the desire to not confront unpleasantness. So large unfortunately critical parts of the culture turn their heads away as we head to a another “never again moment.

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    First there were the Kings the Counts and the Guilds. They denigrated and attacked the emerging middle class. The Clerics at the time constantly attacked their “greed”.

    (See Dierdre McCloskey’s book Bourgeois Dignity)

    Then came the French Revolution, and guess who joined the Aristocrats with their necks in the Guillotine? Yes the small shopkeepers and moderately successful businessmen.

    Then Marx and Engels turned it into a science, they developed the political science whereby the elite, join the underclass in a war against the middle class, which is exactly what socialism really is.

    The New Deal attacked the small businessman in favor of big business and unions. This has ever since been the lifeblood of the Democrat party. Hatred of small and medium business, hatred of the bourgeoisie, Rule by the elites, academics, big corporations, and big labor.

    Everywhere, in every nation, the middle class mostly just wants a civil and criminal court system, some basic infrastructure, and maybe a basic social safety net, and mostly to be LEFT ALONE!

    • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

      I have purposely not been blogging for two days because I have nothing to add to the constant bloviating about the horrible situation in Colorado.

    • veritaseequitas

      place.
      It’s really quite ironic that all the people that b!tch, moan and whine about the rich and how they have so much, are out there buying lottery tickets every week so they can become rich. When they aren’t buying lottery tickets, they are dreaming about being rich and trying to emulate people who are rich.
      Do people think that by buying into the vision of The O Team, they are going to get rich? Or do they just want everyone to have less so they don’t feel so bad about not having more?

      • acat

        Too many in the media believe they would be allowed into the cloistered ivory towers with the liberal intellectual masters… not understanding that they are seen merely as useful idiots or tools.

        Mew

        * the first estate being the clergy, the second the nobility, the third the proletariat (lumpen or not) …

    • Kyle-MI

      They create policies that seem to be against the rich, but then cut out special exemptions for themselves. The middle class don’t get those exemptions or hand outs and thus get killed in the cross fire.

  • renl57

    For the last 3 years, Krugman and Reich and all the rest have been arguing we need more Keynesian stimulus–more, more, more.

    Well, AFAIK, there is NOTHING in Keynesian theory or any classical economic theory that talks about reviving the economy from the middle class outward. (Isn’t Keynesian economics all about controlling *aggregate* demand?) It’s totally a political gimmick that Obama plucked out of thin air.

    Krugman and other liberals who used to claim to know something about economics, are now twisting themselves into rhetorical pretzels trying to keep up with Obama’s left-wing political rhetoric.

  • Ausonius

    You wrote:

    “The President?s vision is of a permanent, entitled Democratic voting majority comprised of the lower- and working classes, more of a ?meso-class? than a true middle class.”

    Democrat Socialists are not interested in “working classes.” A mechanic might believe that he has a right to keep most of his money and take credit for his success and not be expected to let others sponge from his bank account. In which case, he would not for a Democrat.

    Democrat Socialists (a redundancy?) are depending on the NON-working, NON-income-tax-paying class for their votes, along with those who feel guilty about being successful and therefore feel fine with handing over their pay to robbing, hoodwinking politicians.

    Of interest is why the Dems think they can make this work when it is right now failing so conspicuously in Europe, and has failed already under the extreme form known as Communism. What will make America different from Greece and Italy? More guilty rich than in Milan? More patsies than in Madrid?

    Nothing will make us different from failed and failing Socialist countries: Socialism is doomed to fail. The only difference is that America is not yet completely socialist: the Dems are willing to send us down to guaranteed failure for a short-term (10 years? 40?) political gain.

    • acat

      Unskilled labor, organized, with the intent of large-scale extortion.

      Then, the leadership, and much of the rabble, were eastern European anarchists – now the leadership are the Democrats, but the game remains the same…

      Convert a common, easily led resource – proletariat (and, in the case of #OWS, lumpen proletariat) into political muscle, using *implied* physical intimidation (protesting outside executives’ homes) if they don’t knuckle under. (use of actual physical intimidation as well – SEIU antics)

      History doesn’t repeat, but certain elements keep cropping up….

      Mew

      • Ausonius

        had a similar trend.

        In Rome it led to dictatorships and to imperialism.

        The phenomenon was also seen in the 1930′s with FDR’s attacks on banks and businesses. If the phenomenon is new at all today, it is the degree to which the Dems are willing to consign America to bankruptcy and collapse, if not a kind of civil warfare, to attain their ends, which 30′s Dems may not have done.

        • acat

          Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded ? here and there, now and then ? are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty.

          This is known as “bad luck.”

          – RAH

          • http://www.TerriersOfTheRight.blogspot.com Flagstaff

            can only last as long as there is someone able to buy the bread and pay the performers. Eventually, the cycle closes on itself.

            Steve has written a fine piece here, and it illustrates a failing that’s genetic with Democrats–they keep confusing cause with effect.* Subsets of this failing are their looseness or complete non-acquaintance with the facts, their over-estimation of the benefits of government, and their similar blindness to its dangers and excesses.

            If a business needed government “assistance” to become successful, we wouldn’t have today’s problems with illegal drugs. That’s a booming business and it (we hope) receives no aid from the government to take in billions in profit. In fact, the government can’t even stop it because the power of the market is so great.

            All the government can do is to hamstring honest, legitimate businesses, increase their failure rate and prevent them from adding to our wealth as they should.

            *Steny Hoyer’s claim that “unemployment benefits and food stamps are the two most effective means at our disposal of stimulating the economy” is palpably ridiculous to all of us with average mental skills, except for some of those who are Democrats. Extracting money from one group of people, taking a cut, then giving what is left to another group can’t possibly stimulate the economy, especially when there seems to be an intention to expand it and continue to do so indefinitely. That’s a zero-sum game at best, and psychologically it’s sure to depress the economy because it brings with it negative expectations.

            While I’m at it, let’s replace the phrase “economic uncertainty” with “negative expectations.”

  • jaykali

    We have a republic where citizens have some level of representation so you can get away with kinda saying the govt are also the people, similar to how you can say corporations are people.

    So when he says “we” do things together he means, hey citizens “we” the govt need some more taxes so that “we” the govt can do some more spending and “we” the democratic party can get re-elected.

  • bluemount

    BHO mocks those who say that. “You say you work harder?” BHO mocks that as well. His idea is for those who say all that, those who are trying to run businesses, to get back in line, that they don’t deserve to be ahead of others. It’s the same thought process when he said America is exceptional “just like those who live in other countries feel the same about their own country”. He wants Socialism and those who still think he is a “nice” man are totally ignorant and will be the downfall of this country if they re-elect him.

    • 6eorge Jetson

      Pay no atttention to that man at 1600 Pennsylvania

      Somebody also helped to create the European system that is in such a fine mess.

      • http://www.TerriersOfTheRight.blogspot.com Flagstaff

        “Somebody helped to create this unbelievable American system that we have that allowed you to thrive.”

        Did he forget to follow it with, “And Yours Truly is going to do his level best to change that system to make it more believable. Like Europe. Forget about thriving; you’ll be worried about surviving!“?

        The man is a walking and talking stumble-quote machine. Why aren’t we taking more advantage of him? That statement itself should have been the lead story for Hannity and Limbaugh the next day. Both of them got tied up in the “you didn’t work for it meme” and completely missed his outright admission that it is the system that O is so intent on destroying that has been responsible for our success so far. (There is more to it than that, but we’re talking politics, not an intellectual debate among academics.)

  • ncfamilyman

    to early European mercantilism. But the only history this guy knows is the Dialectic, and that everything naturally tends toward “Progress”. He’s the smallest man in any room he walks into.

  • http://libertynews.com/ mbecker908

    a good chunk of elected Republicans – especially US Senators who are Republicans – wouldn’t disagree with the theory of what he says. Lord knows they’ve been acting like they believe it for 50 years.

    • http://www.TerriersOfTheRight.blogspot.com Flagstaff

      The problem is, it’s only true at all on the most basic and obvious level. Of course we all have “help;” if we didn’t we’d all die in infancy (that has a completely different meaning for Democrats, so I won’t digress further), but success depends on what we do after we get that basic help.

  • http://libertynews.com/ mbecker908

    is changing his campaign slogan from

    FORWARD

    to

    FOREPLAY

    because that’s what typically happens just before you get… well, you know…

    • lineholder

      Wonder how long it will be before it heats up?

    • veritaseequitas

      after all he doesn’t even like the American people all that much.

  • lineholder

    It always bothers me a bit when I hear people make comments along the lines that President Obama is simply ignorant, misguided, or incompetent. He isn’t.

    Everything he does has to be considered within the context of his political philosophy and what he is striving to achieve prior to making any judgment about to what extent he has succeeded or failed.

    We’ve already been provided with evidence that, as far as the Obama admin is concerned, the authority of government is NOT to be questioned and those who do question that authority will face consequences to be defined by the admin (i.e., “if you conform, things will be fine…if not, then be prepared to suffer the consequences of that failure to conform0. They’ve followed this course of action time and time again in dealing with just about everyone who even remotely takes the initiative that in any way goes against the Obama admin agenda.

    Why people still continue to believe that this admin would not follow the same course of action where the economic security, safety and future of the middle class is concerned is something that mystifies me. Of course this admin will do so, if it allows them to achieve their goals. That is consistent with the general character and mentality this admin, led by President Obama, has displayed from the starting point.

    That being the case, the door does swing both ways. What “we” (i.e. gov’t) creates, “we” can also destroy.

    • veritaseequitas

      term “gaffe” when used to describe anything Obama says….as in “you didn’t build that business, someone did that for you.”
      That is his belief system at work, not some stupid off the cuff remark he made in a moment of distraction.
      Watch, he will be put back on TOTUS – his drug of choice, to keep him in line.

      • lineholder

        When he speaks from his heart, what he truly desires is revealed.

        I genuinely believe that as more Americans become aware of what it is he and his ilk are striving to succeed in doing to this country, it will be rejected. But the truth has to be revealed first, doesn’t it?

        • veritaseequitas

          But it won’t take his handlers long to realize that he is alienating people with his blatant socialism and so they will put a stop to it in whatever way they can.

      • flguy

        was the same, that this was no “gaffe,” but an obvious statement of what Obama truly believes. I’m glad that this was his response. This president is dangerous to the Republic, and wants to tear it down brick by brick. That we’ve elected someone who obviously hates America is absolutely horrific, and shows us just how important educating the electorate of this nation truly is.

        • http://www.TerriersOfTheRight.blogspot.com Flagstaff

          I wonder if that’s because the media only reported it on the 2:30 p.m. half-hour news break, then dropped it.

          Bill O’Reilly is one of the most guilty of those lineholder and veritas write about. He refuses to believe the evidence in front of his face, that “[t]his president is dangerous to the Republic, and wants to tear it down brick by brick.”

          He may not want to tear it completely down, but he is at least both a fascist and a totalitarian. Those aren’t pejorative terms, they are descriptions of Obama’s behavior. Sensibly, one can only believe for a certain time that Obama is making mistakes. After that, one must assume he’s doing what he intends to do. Then it doesn’t matter what he is called, it only matters what his objectives are, and you can see his objectives by observing what he does.

    • http://www.TerriersOfTheRight.blogspot.com Flagstaff

      The Obamatons are in complete agreement with it. They flaunt their power because they can, ignoring the legal constraints that other Presidents have lived with for over 230 years. Even Andrew Jackson wasn’t as eager to assert his power as The Won is.

  • rightlane1111

    It’s My new blog

    This addresses this subject in some detail.

  • rightlane1111
  • rightlane1111

    It’s my blog. I hope you all like it.

  • Pingback: Website

  • Pingback: Charles Wish

  • Pingback: Cinderella Zartman

  • Pingback: electronic cigarette

  • Pingback: boston cleaning company

  • Pingback: Welcome to My Blog

  • Pingback: Car Forum

  • Pingback: ropa para bebes recien nacidos

  • Pingback: zakopane noclegi

  • Pingback: skype download

  • Pingback: Mining Technology

  • Pingback: Serwis randkowy

  • Pingback: Sizegenetics testimonials

  • Pingback: copper distillation equipment

  • Pingback: ropa para bebes comprar

  • Pingback: outdoors activities

  • Pingback: Fisch Futter

  • Pingback: แทงบอล

  • Pingback: Links Eintragen

  • Pingback: examine my source

  • Pingback: Investment Opportunities

  • Pingback: home water distillers

  • Pingback: BBCAT

  • Pingback: play now

  • Pingback: Koi

  • Pingback: bankruptcy

  • Pingback: kozmetika pre zeny

  • Pingback: Payday Loans Online

  • Pingback: diet mountain dew lyrics

  • Pingback: dieta proteinowa przepisy

  • Pingback: Fusevision.com.sg

  • Pingback: dallas recaning service

  • Pingback: Obdulia Clara

  • Pingback: Britany Heisser

  • Pingback: Pool Shop

  • Pingback: Darren Niemela

  • Pingback: Granville Chough

  • Pingback: DVD to iPad Mini

  • Pingback: finish touchup

  • Pingback: serwis randkowy

  • Pingback: Buy swtor credits

  • Pingback: Darryl Samy

  • Pingback: umow sie na randke

  • Pingback: wielu ludzi w jednym miejscu

  • Pingback: najlepsza randka

  • Pingback: ads for mobile

  • Pingback: Aquariumfilter

  • Pingback: wielu ludzi w jednym miejscu

  • Pingback: www.paydayloanstim.com

  • Pingback: Keli Simonetty

  • Pingback: rewelacyjny portla randkowy

  • Pingback: randki internetowe

  • Pingback: Power Point

  • Pingback: http://www.sheshop.info/obesity-epidemic-shows-perils-to-health-reform/

  • Pingback: extended auto warranty comparison

  • Pingback: hines real estate investment trust

  • Pingback: find out more

  • Pingback: customer satisfaction survey results

  • Pingback: Explore Talent Headquarters

  • Pingback: diamond eternity rings

  • Pingback: Live In Nanny

  • Pingback: Lilia Dudas

  • Pingback: retirement homes south

  • Pingback: Paul Cozzy

  • Pingback: Alexis Fyler

  • Pingback: news

  • Pingback: randki internetowe

  • Pingback: rewelacyjny portla randkowy

  • Pingback: Arkadas Bul

  • Pingback: strona z randkami

  • Pingback: overseas

  • Pingback: odszukaj milosc swego zycia

  • Pingback: cheap advertisement

  • Pingback: upon Yahoo

  • Pingback: SEO Services Australia

  • Pingback: Mining

  • Pingback: no fax payday loans

  • Pingback: casino gaming

  • Pingback: Marianne Perez

  • Pingback: Morris Stuedemann

  • Pingback: Kathryne Pavis

  • Pingback: dry cleaner

  • Pingback: star wars 7 story

  • Pingback: Emory Stasny

  • Pingback: to learn wealth creation methods

  • Pingback: built great morning

  • Pingback: Carie Bazan

  • Pingback: wedding planner italy

  • Pingback: Terrell Schlick

  • Pingback: I loved this

  • Pingback: great price

  • Pingback: have faith in

  • Pingback: Best of Twitter

  • Pingback: Marlin Borchardt

  • Pingback: Don Jaggers

  • Pingback: bgdfgdfgdfgdf

  • Pingback: Butterball

  • Pingback: spectrum investment advisors

  • Pingback: Ulrike Parkison

  • Pingback: Ronald Josten

  • Pingback: Kira Sturdy

  • Pingback: Renata Stepanik

  • Pingback: alfileres de novia

  • Pingback: Technology news

  • Pingback: Remote Control

  • Pingback: lecteur datamatrix

  • Pingback: Glady Lampke

  • Pingback: read far more

  • Pingback: Diseño web barato

  • Pingback: noclegi roztocze

  • Pingback: Allevamento Rottweiler

  • Pingback: active instagram followers

  • Pingback: "??? ????? ????"

  • Pingback: ps3 games

  • Pingback: meio ambiente

  • Pingback: mold testing services

  • Pingback: Dumpster Rental

  • Pingback: Dumpster Rental

  • Pingback: weight loss diet

  • Pingback: Youtube Make Money

  • Pingback: Willena Honsberger

  • Pingback: Annamaria Radar

  • Pingback: online dating

  • Pingback: babies r us registry checklist

  • Pingback: logo quiz game

  • Pingback: annual free credit report

  • Pingback: nsa hookups

  • Pingback: bear grylls messer

  • Pingback: my latest post

  • Pingback: Organo Gold Scam

  • Pingback: tscm

  • Pingback: Tree Surgeon Nottingham

  • Pingback: super cheap car insurance

  • Pingback: sofy rozkładane

  • Pingback: las vegas bankruptcy lawyer

  • Pingback: Chiropractor boardman

  • Pingback: Christene Martensen

  • Pingback: honda 125

  • Pingback: Medical Practice Marketing

  • Pingback: Darron Zarro

  • Pingback: texas driver education

  • Pingback: Irena Griggers

  • Pingback: international trade center

  • Pingback: Bryce Paz

  • Pingback: Stacy Daniels

  • Pingback: ldlhdlcholesterollevels.org

  • Pingback: psn

  • Pingback: texas driver education

  • Pingback: gigi spice videos

  • Pingback: Jacquelin Tamplin

  • Pingback: lida satis

  • Pingback: Homepage

  • Pingback: look what I found

  • Pingback: Lane Tartaglino

  • Pingback: Ernie Classon

  • Pingback: vakantie oostenrijk

  • Pingback: buy hip hop beats with hooks

  • Pingback: http://naginata.cnx.rice.edu:9090/member_profile/cornelia2012