The Democrat Dilemma: Do We Save Kevin McCarthy?

AP Photo/Andrew Harnik

In a CNN exclusive, correspondents reveal House Democrat internal discussions on the chaotic situation that could ensue if any member of the House of Representatives moves to vote out Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy.

Advertisement

In his bid to become speaker of the House, Rep. Kevin McCarthy agreed to a number of concessions to secure the support of Republicans who originally opposed him. One was a rule change to allow just a single member to try to force him from office.

Under the new House rules passed Monday, only one member of Congress — Democrat or Republican — is needed to bring a "motion to vacate," which forces a vote on removing the speaker. That would need only a simple majority of the House to pass to oust McCarthy.

McCarthy has failed on key legislation of his speakership, namely the Defense spending bill, and a government shutdown is imminent. Under the new rules, any member of the House, whether Democrat or Republican, can move to have him removed, but the actual removal would require a simple majority of the full House of Representatives.

House Democrats have begun internal discussions about how to deal with the prospects of a chaotic situation: The possibility that Speaker Kevin McCarthy could lose his job in an unprecedented vote on the floor.

While no decisions have been made, some of the party’s moderates are privately signaling they’d be willing to cut a deal to help McCarthy stave off a right-wing revolt – as long as the speaker meets their own demands.

Advertisement

According to the report, publicly, the leaders are not weighing in, but privately, they are cautioning members to keep their options open, particularly as the government funding discussions are still in play.

Publicly, Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries has not weighed in on how he’d want his members to manage a challenge to McCarthy’s speakership, saying it’s hypothetical at this point. But privately, Jeffries has counseled his members to keep their powder dry, according to multiple sources, a recognition it’s better for Democrats to keep their options open as the government funding fight plays outs.

“If somehow Democrats are asked to be helpful, it’s not just going to have to be out of the kindness of our hearts,” Democratic Rep. Dan Kildee of Michigan, told CNN. “If Kevin can’t govern with just his part – which clearly he can’t – and he wants to have a conversation with us about how to do that, we are going to have a policy conversation.”

CNN asked McCarthy if he would require soliciting Democrats to save his speakership, but McCarthy remained mum on the prospect.

The private discussions have picked up steam in recent days, as a handful of hardline GOP members dig in against a series of spending bills – an effort that could catapult the government into a shutdown – and as any move the speaker takes to advance a short-term spending bill with Democrats could trigger the end of his speakership.

If McCarthy’s position was threatened with a so-called motion to vacate, and there were five Republicans backing it, Democrats would have a major role in deciding McCarthy’s fate.

Advertisement

Whether McCarthy is spared by his own party or his speakership requires saving by the Democrats, it is going to require he give concessions. What cost McCarthy will pay to either side is yet to be seen.

But members who spoke to CNN made clear that any Democratic help would come at a cost. And their asking price for saving his speakership, Democratic members say, is a bipartisan deal to avoid a shutdown – a route McCarthy is not yet prepared to take, as Republicans are still trying to find consensus on a GOP plan to fund the government.


Recommended

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on RedState Videos