« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

How to Structure a Political Economy

The last few years of taxpayer-funded bailouts, backstops, and so-called “stimulus” spending have left Americans with a political economy in which Washington, not the market, decides where to allocate capital. Until now, Washington’s interventions have been put together in haphazard fashion – $300 billion here, $700 billion there, etc. But under the guise of “financial reform,” Democrats last Friday unveiled their plan to make this political economy permanent.

As the language of the 2,000-page Dodd-Frank financial regulatory reform package was finalized, Sen. Chris Dodd (D-CT) channeled Speaker Pelosi’s now-infamous line about ObamaCare. According to The Washington Post, a teary-eyed Sen. Dodd proudly proclaimed:

“No one will know until this is actually in place how it works.”

While Sen. Dodd’s comment speaks volumes about the endless unintended consequences of this legislation (and the fact that Democrats really don’t know what they’re doing), he is not entirely accurate. There are quite a few things we already know about how Dodd-Frank will work.

Winners and Losers – Instead of using and enhancing existing legal structures like the bankruptcy process, the bill gives broad new powers to the same bureaucrats who failed to see the current crisis forming. These powers include the ability to takeover and break up private companies with little or no reason (Sections 113, 165, 203, and 210). The Executive Branch would have every opportunity to abuse these powers to pick winners and losers for political reasons.

Taxpayer Bailouts – Taxpayers will pay the costs of these takeovers upfront out of the Treasury (Section 210). This taxpayer bailout is supposed to be paid back later by other financial firms, but the five biggest banks in the country alone reported more than $8.5 trillion in assets as of March 31, 2010. The cost of another financial crisis could quite conceivably rise to trillions of dollars – making the prospect of repayment unrealistic.

Consumer Restrictions – The bill creates a “Consumer Financial Protection Bureau” (CFPB) with jurisdiction over all sorts of financial products offered by banks and non-banks (Sections 1002 and 1021). Non-bank financial products include your Sears credit card and even agreements to repay your auto mechanic or orthodontist in monthly installments. Mortgages, personal loans, payday loans and check cashing services will also be subject to new restrictions in the name of “protecting” consumers from their own choices. While there is a clear need for more responsible lending standards than were used in recent years, this CFPB will make credit more inaccessible even for credit-worthy families and entrepreneurs.

Higher Consumer Costs – To offset the cost of the bill, Democrats are levying a $19 billion so-called “bank tax” (Section 1601). Of course, banks will not actually pay these costs in the long-run – their customers will pay in the form of higher rates and fees. So say goodbye to your free checking account.

Hoarding Capital – While banks need to keep their reserves at responsible levels, the stringent new leverage restrictions dictated by politicians (Sections 171 and 616) will again leave even credit-worthy consumers struggling to get a loan.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac – Who? Despite their intimate involvement in the financial meltdown and their perpetual taxpayer bailout ($145 billion and counting), the bill neglects to make much-needed reforms to these failed and insolvent entities.

No one denies the need for reforms that actually address the root causes of the financial crisis (House Republicans unveiled our plan, H.R. 3310, over a year ago), but the Dodd-Frank bill doesn’t qualify.

That’s not to say it does not accomplish anything. On the contrary, this bill would institutionalize too-big-to-fail, give politicians and bureaucrats greater control over the economy, ensure a bailout-filled future, restrict access to credit, inhibit job creation, and prevent economic growth. In fact, it is exactly the type of plan you’d expect if you agree with Treasury Secretary Geithner that the U.S. economy can no longer lead the global economy. After all, a political economy driven by Washington dictates will never be able to compete with a market-based economy driven by the actions of American families and businesses.

COMMENTS

  • drfredc

    Welcome to Hope & Change — Obama’s New Class Order. Obama’s New Class Order has 3 basic classes — the Privileged, Collectors, and Serfs.

    The Privileged are the unions (especially public unions), greens, attorneys, left wing politicians, and assorted others. They generally live by their own set of rules outside of the normal dynamics of market forces, derive most of their benefits from other’s life energy, and are protected by various self constructed legal firewalls from common sense behavior. After they’ve prettied themselves with other people’s life energy, they pass any trickle of life energy that’s left back to the Serfs to keep them thinking the Privileged have the Serf’s best interests in mind.

    The Collectors are the successful folks in the private sector whose life energy creates, supports, and/or manages much of the private marketplace. They’ve been selected by the Privileged to collect and pass on enough life energy from the private sector necessary to support the Privileged. Currently, the magic number defining oneself as a Collector appears to be $250,000 of income a year.

    The Serfs are basically everyone else struggling along in the private sector. They spend most of their life energy toiling away so they can buy the basics of the private sector from the Collectors, who in turn pass that revenue to the Privileged. The Privileged return a trickle of the Serf’s own life energy back to the Serfs so the Serf’s can appear to afford various essential benefits of a civilized society. The Privileged use this trickle of the Serf’s own energy back to the Serf’s to buy the votes and continued loyalty of enough Serfs to keep the Obama’s Class Order moving along to the general benefit of the Privileged.

    ===========
    Privileged’s Hope is that no one will notice the fatal flaw in the New Class Order. Everything adds up just fine when it comes to counting votes, but not so well when counting money. Obama’s New Class Order is a quick multi-trillion dollar lined path to moral and fiscal bankruptcy for our freedom and liberty loving society.

    Be not worried, the Privileged have secured their golden parachute when the crash comes.

  • E Pluribus Unum

    It’s really not, of course. Not after what we’ve seen to date by this bunch.

    Simply put, the Democrats are the enemy of freedom, the enemy of free markets, the enemy of free elections.

  • Joliphant

    nt

  • johnt

    sub-titled, squeeze ‘em till they bleed bill.
    Ah yes, what would legislation be without provision for the federal government to ,in it’s wisdom, pick winners and losers. Who or what knows better? And gifted with Solomonic or Periclean genius, who else to craft and guide this life giving measure through the labyrinth of a venal Congress, than the seers, Barny Frank and Chris Dodd?

    May we be soon blessed with these two wizards managing the soon to be bloated, very bloated, coffers of the DNC. The Swiss bank accounts and stuffed pillows we can forget about.
    So this is what “progressives” mean by progress?

  • reddog53

    Representative Price, your post and work to defeat this bill are very much appreciated!

    The news that they were unsure enough of the 60 votes that they retraced their steps to the Conference Room is welcome news….but we can’t let Senators Brown, Snowe and the others sell their votes back for a measley $19 Billion!

    No one would agree to buying a car with leather seats, GPS, 41 MPG and tires that explode 30 minutes after leaving the dealer.

    This notion that ‘parts of the bill’ are acceptable is unacceptable. If some parts are OK, break them off and pass them and destroy the rest of the wreckage they’re attached to!!!

  • mdd1956

    is acceptable.

    Principles matter,
    Dodd / Frank don’t have any,
    the Obama crowd have the wrong ones.

    Another perfect infomercial

  • pittbull

    I’ve got it! Disposable voters!
    Does everyone need to be reminded that this government couldn’t operate a house of prostitution and sell whiskey?
    If I need a banker, I’ll call my banker. My banker is a little sharper than a bureaucrat on a really bad day.

  • dude

    Very depressing. I find everything these people to to us depressing. Nothing but a bunch of bad news bears. If ever two people need to be voted out of office its Dodd and Franks.